Monday, June 30, 2014

The Pitfall of Pragmatism - GBC Bulletin Column #53


We sometimes sing the hymn by Isaac Watts, the closing stanza of which exclaims what should be a prayer of everyone in this congregation: “We long to see thy churches full/That all the chosen race/May, with one voice and heart and soul/Sing thy redeeming grace.” This is a noble longing and not in any way to be despised. The Scriptures are filled with the concept of people flocking to the place of worship to join in a foreshadowing of the heavenly assembly when a vast multitude which no man can number will exclaim the absolute worthiness of Christ to reign over and receive all things. The first church had over three thousand people (to which many were added each day) who were devoted ‘to the apostles’ teaching and fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers’ (Acts 2:42).

Clearly then, God has no problem with a crowd, but when the crowd becomes the object of our attention, and drawing one is an end in and of itself, then the goal to which we strive is no longer the glory of God in the exaltation of Christ and we have made an idol around which our faith and practice is centred. Instead of building the body of Christ we end up catering to the wishes, wants, and ‘felt needs’ of individuals losing sight of both our message and our mission. H. B. Charles Jr., Pastor of the Shiloh Metropolitan Baptist Church in Jacksonville, Florida, recently made the point:

"There was a time when church saw itself as pilgrims travelling together through a foreign land on their way home. Now we are more prone to view ourselves as tourists who just happen to be on the same bus with different and competing interests, priorities, and agendas. As a result many worldly philosophies like individualism, relativism, subjectivism, and pragmatism now dominate church life...There are so many pastors and churches these days that seem to be willing to do virtually anything just to draw a crowd. Leaning over to reach the world, the church has fallen in."

The problem is not being pragmatic, by which I mean wisely discerning what opportunities can best be exploited for gospel proclamation. The problem is pragmatism, when wisdom and discernment are often discarded together with any clear presence of the gospel in order to draw a crowd. Drawn they may be - but to a show, not to the Saviour and a life of service. 

All of this is done in the name of so-called ‘relevancy’ and ‘cultural engagement’, terms that the people who use them don’t even seem to understand. In the quest to ‘be relevant’, churches have actually become irrelevant as people are given what they want not what they need and are made to feel comfortable rather than convicted. How can something be described as ‘relevant’ if there is no challenge to the norm, no counter-culturally transformative impact, no clear word that gets into people’s hearts and lives and calls for radical change?  And as for cultural engagement, an outsider observing many churches might be forgiven for thinking that this refers to that stage of a romance preceding marriage, not the clash of battle that comes with war. However, all that the Bible tells me about spiritual warfare leads me to say that truly engaging culture is not about putting a ring on it, but thrusting a sword through it, that sword being the Word of God prayerfully proclaimed in the power of the Holy Spirit to a demon-enslaved world. Only then is our end achieved. The end is not that the church is filled with spectators. The end is that God is glorified as the church is filled with servants joyfully singing his redeeming grace. To this end we must strive. 

This was printed in the worship bulletin of Grace Baptist Church (Wood Green) on 29 June 2014.

No comments:

Post a Comment